Common Mistakes in Data Collection & Displays

64 common pitfalls across 16 concepts, including 16 recurring stuck points

These are the pitfalls students hit across all 16 data collection & displays concepts, from Data Collection, Statistical Question and Categorical Data onward. Each entry names the concept it comes from, so you can tell a slip from a genuine gap and go straight to the explanation.

1
Data Collection
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to data collection but skip the recognition step: Is the job to plan how to get the answers, such as asking people, watching, or measuring, before any chart is made? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

2

Only asking friends (biased sample)

3

Changing the question mid-survey

4

Forgetting to record some responses

5

Students often know a procedure related to statistical question but skip the recognition step: Would asking this question to many different people or things give different answers, rather than one fixed fact? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

6

Thinking any number question is statistical

7

Forgetting the variability requirement

8

Confusing questions about one individual with questions about a group

9
Categorical Data
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to categorical data but skip the recognition step: Is each answer a name for a group, like a color or a pet type, that you can count but not add or average? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

10

Trying to calculate mean of categories

11

Confusing with numerical data

12

Using wrong graph type

13

Students often know a procedure related to data representation but skip the recognition step: Must you decide which kind of chart, table, or graph fits this data before drawing or reading it? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

14

Using the wrong type of graph for the data

15

Not labeling axes

16

Using inconsistent scales

17
Tally Chart
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to tally chart but skip the recognition step: Is each item being recorded as one quick stroke as it happens, to be counted up in fives afterwards? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

18
Tally Chart
Mistake

Forgetting to cross at 5

19
Tally Chart
Mistake

Miscounting groups of 5

20
Tally Chart
Mistake

Messy marks that blend together

21
Frequency Table
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to frequency table but skip the recognition step: Do you need each category or value listed once, beside a written number saying how many times it occurred? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

22

Missing categories

23

Counting errors

24

Not including all values from original data

25
Pictograph
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to pictograph but skip the recognition step: Does each picture in the display stand for an amount given in a key, such as one star for 5 votes? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

26
Pictograph
Mistake

Not using consistent symbol values

27
Pictograph
Mistake

Forgetting to include a key

28
Pictograph
Mistake

Using half-symbols incorrectly

29
Bar Graph
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to bar graph but skip the recognition step: Are you comparing amounts for separate named groups, with one bar per group read against a number scale? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

30
Bar Graph
Mistake

Bars not starting at zero (misleading)

31
Bar Graph
Mistake

Unequal bar widths

32
Bar Graph
Mistake

Categories not clearly labeled

33
Line Graph
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to line graph but skip the recognition step: Is one amount measured again and again over time, so joining the points shows it rising or falling? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

34
Line Graph
Mistake

Using for categorical data (should use bar graph)

35
Line Graph
Mistake

Uneven time intervals

36
Line Graph
Mistake

Connecting unrelated points

37

Students often know a procedure related to line plot (dot plot) but skip the recognition step: Is there one number answer per person or item, each shown as an X above its value on a number line? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

38

Uneven spacing on number line

39

Overlapping marks

40

Using for too much data

41
Dot Plot
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to dot plot but skip the recognition step: Are you describing the shape of a small numerical data set, with its clusters, gaps and outliers, using one dot per observation? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

42
Dot Plot
Mistake

Inconsistent dot sizes

43
Dot Plot
Mistake

Not aligning dots properly

44
Dot Plot
Mistake

Using for very large datasets

45
Pie Chart
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to pie chart but skip the recognition step: Do the groups together make up one whole, and is the question about what share of that whole each group takes? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

46
Pie Chart
Mistake

Using a pie chart when the categories do not sum to a whole

47
Pie Chart
Mistake

Reading slice area casually without checking the actual percentages

48
Pie Chart
Mistake

Comparing very similar slice sizes when a bar graph would be clearer

49
Stem-and-Leaf Plot
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to stem-and-leaf plot but skip the recognition step: Do you need a display that groups the values by their leading digits while keeping every exact value readable? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

50

Writing leaves out of order

51

Using inconsistent stem units

52

Forgetting to include a key that explains what a stem and leaf mean

53
Histogram
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to histogram but skip the recognition step: Are many numerical values being grouped into equal ranges, with the count in each range shown by touching bars? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

54
Histogram
Mistake

Gaps between neighboring bars (bars should touch; an empty space appears only where a bin's count is 0)

55
Histogram
Mistake

Unequal bin widths

56
Histogram
Mistake

Confusing with bar graphs

57
Box Plot
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to box plot but skip the recognition step: Are you comparing groups using only five numbers each: the minimum, the quartiles, the median, and the maximum? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

58
Box Plot
Mistake

Thinking the box shows all data (just middle 50%)

59
Box Plot
Mistake

Misreading whisker length as sample size

60
Box Plot
Mistake

Forgetting to mark outliers separately when using the 1.5*IQR rule

61
Misleading Graphs
Stuck Point

Students often know a procedure related to misleading graphs but skip the recognition step: Are the numbers themselves true, but the way they are drawn makes a difference look bigger or smaller than it is? That leads to a calculation or graph that looks reasonable but answers a different question.

62

Trusting the visual without checking the numbers

63

Not checking axis scales

64

Accepting cherry-picked time ranges that hide the bigger trend