Peel the label off a soup can and flatten it. It is a rectangle. Its height is the can's height, h. Its width is the distance once around the can, the circumference 2πr, because the label wrapped around exactly once. So the curved side has area 2πr×h. Add the top and bottom lids, each a circle of area πr2, and the full surface is SA=2πr2+2πrh.
For a can with radius 4 cm and height 12 cm, the lids give 2π(16)=32π and the side gives 2π(4)(12)=96π, a total of 128π≈402 cm². Here the side is three times the lids. On long, thin cylinders like pipes the side is nearly everything; on flat ones like a coin, the two faces dominate.
Two look-alikes use the same numbers. Volume of a cylinder, πr2h, measures what fits inside, in cm³. Area of a circle, πr2, is just one lid. Surface area is the whole skin, all three pieces, in cm². Real objects often lack a piece: a drinking glass has one base and a pipe has none, so check which ends are closed.
Think of it like this. A cylinder's surface comes apart like a cardboard tube with two coins as caps. Slit the tube and it lies flat as a rectangle; the caps are circles. The rectangle's long side must equal the distance around a coin, or the tube would not close. Real cans have rims and seams, so they use a little more metal than the formula gives.
Core idea. Surface area of a cylinder is two circular bases plus the rectangle that wraps around the side.