Cut a pizza into 16 thin slices and lay them in a row, points alternating up and down like the teeth of a zip. The row looks like a bumpy rectangle. Its height is the length of one slice, the radius r. Its long side uses half of the crust (the other half runs along the opposite edge), so it is half the circumference, πr. With thinner slices the bumps flatten out, and the rectangle's area, r×πr, becomes the circle's area: πr2.
The square is the important part. Area counts unit squares, and when the radius grows the circle gets wider in every direction at once. A circle of radius 2 m holds 4π≈12.6 m²; radius 4 m holds 16π≈50.3 m². Doubling the radius multiplies the area by 4, not by 2.
Circumference uses the same circle and the same π but answers a different question. 2πr is a length, the crust; πr2 is a surface, the cheese. A given diameter has to be halved before squaring: a circle 10 cm wide has r=5, so its area is 25π, not 100π.
Think of it like this. A circle's area is like a dartboard made of thin rings. Each ring further out is longer than the one inside it, so it adds more area, which is why area races ahead as the radius grows. Cut the rings and straighten them into strips, shortest on top, and they stack into a triangle with base 2πr and height r: area πr2.
Core idea. Area of a circle is the flat space inside it, πr2.