Closure Property Examples: 47 Problems with Answers

Worked examples of Closure Property to try before you open each solution, then practice problems with answers.

Worked Examples

Example 1

easy
Are whole numbers closed under addition? Test with 5+7 and 12+0. Explain what closure means.
Show solution

Answer

Yes — whole numbers are closed under addition

First step

1.
Closure means: performing the operation on two members of the set always gives another member of the same set.

Full solution

  1. 2.
    Test: 5+7=12. Is 12 a whole number? Yes.
  2. 3.
    Test: 12+0=12. Is 12 a whole number? Yes.
  3. 4.
    Whole numbers are closed under addition: the sum of any two whole numbers is always a whole number.
A set is closed under an operation if applying the operation to any elements of the set always produces another element in the set.

Example 2

medium
Are whole numbers closed under subtraction? Provide a counterexample if not.

Example 3

medium
Are the integers closed under exponentiation? Justify with a counterexample if not.

Example 4

medium
Is the set {−1,1} closed under multiplication?

Example 5

hard
Decide whether the set of 2×2 integer matrices is closed under addition and under matrix multiplication.

Example 6

hard
Show that the set of odd integers is NOT closed under addition but IS closed under multiplication.

Example 7

challenge
Show that the set {z∈C:∣z∣=1} is closed under multiplication.

Practice Problems

Try each one, then open the solution to compare your method.

Example 1

easy
Are integers closed under multiplication? Test with (−3)×4 and (−2)×(−5).

Example 2

medium
Are integers closed under division? Provide a counterexample if not.

Example 3

easy
Is the set of integers closed under addition? (yes/no)

Example 4

easy
Is the set of integers closed under division? (yes/no)

Example 5

easy
Are the natural numbers (1,2,3,…) closed under subtraction? (yes/no)

Example 6

easy
Are the even integers closed under addition? (yes/no)

Example 7

easy
Are the odd integers closed under addition? (yes/no)

Example 8

easy
Are the whole numbers closed under multiplication? (yes/no)

Example 9

easy
Is the set {0,1} closed under multiplication? (yes/no)

Example 10

easy
Are the positive integers closed under addition? (yes/no)

Example 11

medium
Is the set of rational numbers closed under division (excluding division by zero)? Explain.

Example 12

medium
Give a counterexample showing the natural numbers are not closed under division.

Example 13

medium
Is the set of irrational numbers closed under addition? Give reasoning.

Example 14

medium
Is the set {−1,0,1} closed under multiplication? Check all products.

Example 15

medium
Are the multiples of 5 closed under addition? Justify.

Example 16

medium
Is division by zero a reason that nonzero rationals are 'almost' closed under division? Explain in one line.

Example 17

medium
Are the negative integers closed under multiplication? Justify.

Example 18

medium
Are the whole numbers closed under subtraction? Give a counterexample if not.

Example 19

medium
Is the set {1} closed under multiplication? Under addition?

Example 20

challenge
Determine whether the set {0,1,2} under addition modulo 3 is closed.

Example 21

challenge
Is the set of perfect squares closed under multiplication? Justify.

Example 22

challenge
Show that the set of odd integers is closed under multiplication but not addition.

Example 23

easy
Is the set of integers closed under subtraction?

Example 24

easy
Are the multiples of 3 closed under addition?

Example 25

easy
Are the multiples of 3 closed under multiplication?

Example 26

easy
Is the set of even integers closed under multiplication?

Example 27

easy
Is the set of positive rationals closed under multiplication?

Example 28

easy
Are the negative integers closed under addition?

Example 29

medium
Are the irrational numbers closed under multiplication?

Example 30

medium
Is the set {0,1,2,3} closed under addition modulo 4?

Example 31

medium
Is the set of all real numbers closed under taking square roots?

Example 32

medium
Are the prime numbers closed under multiplication?

Example 33

medium
Are the powers of 2 ({1,2,4,8,… }) closed under multiplication?

Example 34

medium
Are the powers of 2 closed under addition?

Example 35

hard
Is the set S={a+b2:a,b∈Q} closed under multiplication?

Example 36

hard
Are the integers ≥0 closed under the operation a∘b=a+b−ab?

Example 37

hard
Is the set of polynomials with integer coefficients closed under multiplication?

Example 38

hard
Is the set of n×n invertible real matrices closed under multiplication?

Example 39

challenge
Is the set {a+b23:a,b∈Q} closed under multiplication?

Example 40

challenge
Is the set of all sequences of zeros and ones (bitstrings of fixed length n) closed under bitwise XOR?

What to focus on

Core idea: A set is closed under an operation when combining members always lands back inside that set.

Common stuck point: The procedure for operation closure is the easy part; the trap is declaring closure from a few examples. Asking "Does combining any two members of the set always give a result still in the set?" first is what keeps a correct-looking calculation from being attached to the wrong concept.

Ask yourself: Does combining any two members of the set always give a result still in the set?

Concept recap

A set is closed under an operation if performing that operation on members of the set always produces a result that is also in the set. For example, integers are closed under addition.

Closure is like a board game whose moves never take a piece off the board. Whole numbers with addition form such a game: every move lands on another whole-number square. Subtraction is a move that can slide a piece off the edge, past 0 into the negatives, so whole numbers are not closed under it.

Read the full lesson on Closure Property

Background knowledge

These ideas may be useful before you work through the harder examples.

additionsubtractionmultiplicationdivision