Think of a set as a club with a membership list, and an operation as a machine that takes two members and produces something. The club is closed under that machine if whatever comes out is always a member too. Take the even numbers under addition: 4+6=10, 12+30=42. Any two even numbers can be written 2a and 2b, and their sum is 2(a+b), also even. No sum can ever leave the club.
Proving closure needs a reason that covers every pair, like that 2(a+b) argument, because you can't test infinitely many examples. Disproving it needs only one counterexample. Odd numbers under addition: 3+5=8, which is even, so the odd numbers are not closed under addition. Odd numbers under multiplication, though, are closed: odd times odd is always odd.
Closure depends on both the set and the operation. Whole numbers are closed under multiplication but not division, since 7÷2=3.5. Rational numbers are closed under division by anything except 0. Don't confuse closure with whether the order of the two numbers matters, which is commutativity, or with whether a step can be undone, which is about inverses.
Think of it like this. Closure is like a board game whose moves never take a piece off the board. Whole numbers with addition form such a game: every move lands on another whole-number square. Subtraction is a move that can slide a piece off the edge, past 0 into the negatives, so whole numbers are not closed under it.
Core idea. A set is closed under an operation when combining members always lands back inside that set.