On this concept: Formula

Not sure which lesson to do first? Find your level and get a plan →

Math · Fractions & Ratios · Grade 3-5

Comparing Fractions

Comparing fractions means deciding which fraction is greater, less, or equal.

ab<cd  ⟺  ad<bc (cross-multiplication comparison, valid when b,d>0)

Quick Answer

Comparing fractions means deciding which fraction is greater, less, or equal. Use it when you need to know which share is bigger: more of a pizza, a longer piece of ribbon, a better score. When the denominators match, compare the numerators. When the numerators match, the smaller denominator wins, because its pieces are bigger. Otherwise, rename both to a common denominator or compare each one with 12 or 1.

Why This Matters

Deciding whether 23 of a cup is more than 34, or whether a team that won 5 of 8 games did better than one that won 3 of 5, needs a way to compare. Big numbers don't make a big fraction: 310 is less than 12 even though 3 and 10 are bigger numbers. Comparing correctly is also the first step of ordering fractions.

Intuitive Explanation

Two fractions are easy to compare when one of their numbers matches. 58 and 38 are made of the same-size pieces, so 5 pieces beat 3. 13 and 15 each have 1 piece, but thirds are bigger than fifths, so 13 is bigger. Sharing a pizza among 3 people gives each person more than sharing it among 5.

When nothing matches, make something match. To compare 34 and 56, rename both as twelfths: 912 and 1012. Now the pieces are the same size, and 56 is bigger by one twelfth. A faster way here is a benchmark: each fraction is one piece short of a whole, and a missing sixth is smaller than a missing fourth, so 56 is closer to 1.

Both fractions must be of the same whole: half of a small pizza can be less food than a third of a large one. Comparing is also different from adding. 'Which is more, 34 or 58?' wants one of the two fractions as the answer, while 34+58 asks for a new amount, 118.

Think of it like this. Picture two chocolate bars of the same size, cut different ways. The denominator tells how many pieces a bar was cut into, so bigger denominators mean thinner pieces, and the numerator tells how many pieces you hold. Who has more chocolate depends on both numbers. The comparison is only fair when the two bars are the same size.

Core idea. A fraction comparison is only fair when both fractions refer to the same whole.


When to Use

Compare fractions when a question asks which is greater, which is less, which is closer to 1, or asks you to fill in <, > or =. Check first that both fractions are of the same whole. If the question asks for a total or a difference, add or subtract instead. If there are three or more fractions to put in order, use ordering fractions, which repeats this comparison.

Tip. Ask: Am I judging size rather than combining amounts?

How to Recognize It

Before comparing two fractions, check that they are parts of the same whole and look at which of their numbers already match.

  1. Do the two fractions have the same bottom number?

    Then the pieces are the same size, and the bigger top number wins: 58>38. If the bottom numbers differ, look at the top numbers next, or rename both with equivalent fractions.

  2. Do the two fractions have the same top number?

    Then you hold the same number of pieces, and the smaller bottom number means bigger pieces: 35>38. Here the smaller bottom number wins, which surprises many students.

  3. Is one fraction more than a half and the other less than a half?

    Then no renaming is needed: 47 is more than a half, since 4 is more than half of 7, and 25 is less, since 2 is less than half of 5. So 47 is bigger.

  4. Does the question ask for a total, a difference, or a list of three or more fractions?

    A total or a difference means adding or subtracting fractions, and three or more in a row means ordering fractions. Comparing gives only one of three answers: greater, less or equal.

Comparing Fractions compared with Equivalent fractions and Adding fractions

Comparing, renaming and adding fractions all begin by getting the pieces to the same size, often with a common bottom number. What separates them is the answer at the end: a sign like <, proof that two names are equal, or a new amount.

Comparing Fractions

Meaning
Use this when the task asks which fraction is greater, smaller, closest, or equal.
Key test
Am I judging size rather than combining amounts?
Formula
ab<cd  ⟺  ad<bc (cross-multiplication comparison, valid when b,d>0)
Example
Which is larger: 3/4 or 5/8?

Equivalent fractions

Meaning
Shows two fraction names have the same value.
Key test
Use when the fractions land at the same point.
Formula
2/4=1/2
Example
Are these equal?

Adding fractions

Meaning
Finds a total amount.
Key test
Use when parts are being combined.
Formula
1/4+2/4
Example
How much altogether?

Formula & Notation

ab<cd  ⟺  ad<bc (cross-multiplication comparison, valid when b,d>0)
ab<cd  ⟺  ad<bc for b,d>0

How to read it: ab<cd, ab>cd, or ab=cd using <, >, = symbols

Worked Examples

Example 1 — Benchmark comparison

Easy

Which is larger: 3/4 or 5/8?
Show the steps and the answer
  1. Look for a common denominator: 4 goes into 8, so use eighths.

    With pieces the same size, you only need to compare how many pieces there are.

  2. Rename 34: multiply the top and bottom by 2 to get 68.

    Each fourth is two eighths, so 3 fourths are 6 eighths.

  3. Compare the numerators: 6 is more than 5, so 68>58, and 34>58.

    Six eighths is more than five eighths by one eighth.

  4. Check with a benchmark: 12=48, so 58 is just one eighth past half, while 34 is two eighths past half.

    The fraction further past 12 is the larger one, which agrees.

Answer: 3/4

Takeaway: Rename to the same denominator; then the larger numerator is the larger fraction.

Example 2 — Combining amounts

Standard

What is 3/4+5/8?
Show the steps and the answer
  1. Read the question: it has a plus sign and asks 'what is', so it wants a total.

    A total is a new amount, not a choice between the two fractions.

  2. Rename to eighths: 34=68.

    Pieces must be the same size before they can be added, just as for comparing.

  3. Add the numerators: 68+58=118.

    Six eighths and five eighths make eleven eighths, and the piece size stays eighths.

  4. Check the size: 118=138, which is more than either fraction.

    A sum of two positive amounts must be bigger than each of them.

Answer: 3/4+5/8=11/8

Takeaway: 'Which is larger?' picks one of the fractions; a sum makes a new one. Both start by renaming to a common denominator.

Example 3 — Find the mistake: fractions of different wholes

Application

A small pizza is cut into 6 slices and a large pizza into 12 slices, and all the slices are the same size. Ben ate 12 of the small pizza and Ella ate 13 of the large pizza. Ben says: "I ate more, because 12 is bigger than 13." Find the mistake and correct it.
Show the steps and the answer
  1. Notice the two fractions are of different wholes: a 6-slice pizza and a 12-slice pizza.

    Comparing 12 with 13 only tells who ate more when both are of the same pizza.

  2. Find Ben's slices: half of 6 is 6÷2=3 slices.

    Turning each fraction into slices puts both amounts in the same unit.

  3. Find Ella's slices: a third of 12 is 12÷3=4 slices.

    All the slices are the same size, so counting slices compares the food.

  4. Compare: 4 slices is more than 3, so Ella ate more.

    12>13 is true for one pizza, but here the wholes are different sizes.

Answer: Ella ate more: 4 slices against Ben's 3.

Takeaway: Before comparing two fractions, make sure they are fractions of the same whole.

Where You'll See It

  • Comparing two team records

    One team won 5 of 8 games and another won 3 of 5. Using 40 as a common denominator, that is 2540 against 2440, so the first team has the better record, by just one fortieth.

  • Picking the right wrench

    A bolt needs a wrench just larger than 916 inch. Is a 58 inch wrench bigger? In sixteenths, 58=1016, so yes, by 116 inch.

  • Using the wrong size scoop

    A recipe needs 23 cup of oats, but the only scoop holds 34 cup. In twelfths, 23=812 and 34=912, so a full scoop is a little too much, by 112 cup.

Common Mistakes

  1. The slip: Choosing the fraction with the larger denominator automatically

    Instead: denominators name piece size, not total size by themselves.

  2. The slip: Ignoring the whole

    Instead: fractions must refer to the same whole to compare directly.

  3. The slip: Cross-multiplying without understanding

    Instead: use benchmarks or common denominators to know why the comparison is true.


Mini Practice

Try these on your own. Tap Reveal when you want to check.

  1. Which is larger: 25 or 45?

    Hint: The pieces are the same size. Which fraction has more pieces?

  2. Which is larger: 16 or 14?

    Hint: Think of one pizza cut into 6 pieces and another cut into 4. Which piece is bigger?

  3. Compare 23 and 35 using a common denominator.

    Hint: Rewrite both fractions as fifteenths.

  4. Compare 37 and 59 using 12 as a benchmark.

    Hint: Is each fraction a little less than half or a little more than half?

  5. Zoe ran 34 mile and Jack ran 78 mile. The coach wants to know who ran farther. Should you compare the fractions or add them?

    Hint: Does the coach want a total, or which amount is bigger?

  6. Leo says "38 is bigger than 34, because 8 is bigger than 4." Help Leo.

    Hint: Which pieces are bigger: eighths or fourths?

Want the full set?

50 practice questions for this concept — free to try, every one with a complete worked solution showing the why, not just the answer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is bigger, 78 or 89?

Look at what each one is missing. 78\frac{7}{8} is one eighth short of a whole, and 89\frac{8}{9} is one ninth short. A ninth is a smaller piece than an eighth, so 89\frac{8}{9} is missing less and sits closer to 1. That makes 89\frac{8}{9} the bigger fraction. This trick works for any two fractions that are each one piece short of a whole.

Can I just turn both fractions into decimals?

Yes, and with a calculator it is quick: 58=0.625\frac{5}{8} = 0.625 and 23=0.666…\frac{2}{3} = 0.666\ldots, so 23\frac{2}{3} is bigger. Without a calculator, dividing takes longer than renaming. Decimals help most when the fractions are very close, or when one amount is already a decimal, such as a 0.6 m ribbon against a 58\frac{5}{8} m ribbon.

Is 34 of 8 cookies more than 12 of 16 cookies?

No, even though 34\frac{3}{4} is the bigger fraction. Three quarters of 8 cookies is 6 cookies, while half of 16 cookies is 8 cookies. The bigger fraction gives fewer cookies because its whole is smaller. When the wholes are different, work out the real amounts first and compare those, not the fractions.

Learning Path

Comparing Fractions

You are here

You need Fractions (what the numerator and denominator mean) and Equivalent Fractions (renaming 34 as 912). Comparing adds ways to decide which of two fractions is bigger: same denominators, same numerators, common denominators and benchmarks like 12. Next, Ordering Fractions uses the same tools to rank three or more fractions from least to greatest.

See Also