Not sure which lesson to do first? Find your level and get a plan →

Math · Algebra Fundamentals · Grade 6-8

Checking Solutions

Checking solutions means putting your answer back into the original equation and verifying both sides come out equal.


Quick Answer

Checking solutions means putting your answer back into the original equation and verifying both sides come out equal. Do it every time you finish solving, and never skip it after squaring both sides, clearing fractions or solving an absolute-value equation, because those steps can produce answers that do not work. Work out the left side and the right side separately with your value, and accept the answer only if they match. A check also catches ordinary slips, such as a dropped minus sign.

Why This Matters

A check turns "I think it's 7" into "it is 7": you find out yourself whether an answer is right, before a test or a bill tells you. It is also the only way to spot extraneous answers, numbers that come out of correct algebra but fail the original equation, like x=−2 in x+6=x. Without it you are trusting every line of working, and one sign error is enough to be wrong.

Intuitive Explanation

An equation makes a claim: the left side and the right side are the same number. A solution is a value that makes the claim true, so checking is just testing the claim. Suppose you solved 4x−7=2x+5 and got x=6. Left side: 4(6)−7=17. Right side: 2(6)+5=17. They match, so 6 is a solution. Had you got x=5, the sides would be 13 and 15, and you would know to look for a mistake.

Always check in the original equation, not a later line. The later lines came from your own working, so if a step was wrong, a later line can agree with a wrong answer. The original is the only line you know is correct.

Some steps can create answers that were never there. Squaring both sides of 2x+3=x gives 2x+3=x2, which factors as (x−3)(x+1)=0, so the candidates are 3 and −1. In the original, 9=3 works, but 1=1, not −1. Squaring hid the difference between 1 and −1, because both square to 1. Multiplying both sides by an expression containing x, as when clearing fractions, can add false answers in the same way.

Checking is not the same as evaluating. Evaluating 2x+5 at x=6 gives 17, a value with no verdict; checking compares two sides and ends in yes or no. It also differs from estimating: "about 6" says an answer is reasonable, while a check says it is exactly right.

Think of it like this. Checking a solution is like trying a newly cut key in the lock it was made for. If it turns, the key fits; if not, it was cut wrong. Trying it in a copy of the lock that you made yourself proves nothing, which is why you check in the original equation and not in a later line.

Core idea. Checking a solution substitutes a candidate value into the original condition and confirms both sides truly match.


When to Use

Check whenever you have a candidate answer, and never skip it after squaring both sides, clearing fractions that had x in a denominator, or splitting an absolute value into cases. Substitute into the original equation and compare the two sides. If you only need the value of an expression at a given number, evaluate it instead. If you have not solved yet, solve first; a check needs a specific value to test.

Tip. Ask: Do I have a candidate value that I plug into the original condition to confirm both sides are equal?

How to Recognize It

Before checking, find the original equation or condition from the problem and the specific value you want to test.

  1. Did any step square both sides, multiply by an expression with x in it, or split an absolute value into cases?

    Then a check is required, not optional, because those steps can add answers that do not work. After only adding, subtracting, or dividing by plain numbers, a check is still wise but mainly catches slips.

  2. Is the condition a word problem rather than a bare equation?

    Check the answer against the story, not only your equation: if the equation was set up wrong, the answer will fit the equation and still fail the story. A value of 4.5 people or a negative age also fails the story.

  3. Do you have a specific number to test yet?

    If not, you are still solving, and a check has nothing to work on. Solve first, then check each value you found, one at a time.

  4. Is the condition an inequality rather than an equation?

    Then test a number from inside your answer and one from outside it: the inside one should make the inequality true and the outside one false. Testing only the boundary number checks the line, not the direction.

Checking Solutions compared with Solving, Evaluating, and Estimation

All four rows put numbers into expressions or equations, so they feel like the same job. Ask what the result is for: finding the unknown, getting a value, judging whether a candidate really is a solution, or seeing roughly whether an answer is sensible.

Checking Solutions

Meaning
Use this when you have a candidate answer and need to confirm it satisfies the original equation, especially after squaring or clearing denominators.
Key test
Do I have a candidate value that I plug into the original condition to confirm both sides are equal?
Example
After solving x+6=x, you get candidates x=3 and x=−2. Which are valid?

Solving

Meaning
Produces the candidate value(s) in the first place.
Key test
Use when you still need to find the unknown, not confirm it.
Example
Solve x=3 to get x=9

Evaluating

Meaning
Computes an expression's value at a number, with no true/false verdict.
Key test
Use when you just want the output, not a check against a condition.
Example
Evaluate 2x+1 at x=4 to get 9

Estimation

Meaning
Approximates whether an answer is reasonable, not exactly verified.
Key test
Use for a quick sanity sense, not a definitive check.
Example
50≈7, so the answer near 7 seems plausible

Formula & Notation

How to read it: Substitution verification: evaluate LHS and RHS separately.

Worked Examples

Example 1 — Catch an extraneous root

Easy

After solving x+6=x, you get candidates x=3 and x=−2. Which are valid?
Show the steps and the answer
  1. Test x=3 on the left: 3+6=9=3.

    Work out each side separately with the candidate value.

  2. Compare with the right side, which is 3: the sides match, so x=3 is valid.

    Equal sides in the original equation are what make a value a solution.

  3. Test x=−2: the left side is −2+6=4=2 and the right side is −2.

    A square root sign means the non-negative root, so the left side can never be negative.

  4. Reject x=−2, since 2≠−2.

    It solves the squared equation x+6=x2, because (−2)2=4=−2+6, but not the original, so it is extraneous.

Answer: Only x=3 is valid

Takeaway: After squaring, test every candidate in the original equation; a square root can never equal a negative number.

Example 2 — Just evaluating

Standard

Find the value of x+6 when x=3.
Show the steps and the answer
  1. Look for an equals sign with two sides to compare: there is none, only the expression x+6.

    Without a claim to test, there is nothing to verify, only a value to find.

  2. Substitute x=3: 3+6=9.

    Evaluating replaces the letter with the given number.

  3. Simplify: 9=3.

    The result is a value, not a true-or-false verdict.

Answer: 9=3

Takeaway: Evaluating gives a number; checking compares two sides and gives a yes or no.

Example 3 — Find the mistake: checking the wrong line

Application

Solve 3(x−4)=2x+1. Max writes: "3x−4=2x+1, so x=5. Check: 3(5)−4=11 and 2(5)+1=11, so it's correct." Find the mistake and correct it.
Show the steps and the answer
  1. See where Max checked: in 3x−4=2x+1, his own second line, not the original equation.

    If that line is wrong, a wrong answer can still pass a check against it.

  2. Test x=5 in the original: the left side is 3(5−4)=3 and the right side is 2(5)+1=11.

    3≠11, so 5 is not a solution.

  3. Find the error: 3(x−4) is 3x−12, not 3x−4.

    The 3 multiplies both terms inside the brackets.

  4. Re-solve: 3x−12=2x+1, so x=13.

    Subtracting 2x and adding 12 on both sides isolates x.

  5. Test x=13 in the original: 3(13−4)=27 and 2(13)+1=27.

    The two sides match, so 13 is the solution.

Answer: x=13

Takeaway: Check in the original equation; a later line may already contain the mistake you are trying to catch.

Where You'll See It

  • Sharing a bill with one extra dessert

    Three friends share a $54 bill, and one of them also pays $6 for dessert. Solving 3s+6=54 gives s=16. The check 3(16)+6=54 confirms it: two friends pay $16, the dessert-eater pays $22, and 16+16+22=54.

  • Mixing paint to a target colour

    To make 10 litres of paint that is 30% red from a 50% red paint and a 20% red paint, solve 0.5x+0.2(10−x)=3 to get x=103≈3.3 litres. Checking: 0.5⋅103+0.2⋅203=53+43=3 litres of red, exactly 30% of 10.

  • Testing a spreadsheet formula

    A rule says each of 4 departments pays T−2004+50 dollars of a total cost T. An accountant checks it on a case she can do by hand: with T=1000 each pays 200+50=250, and 4×250=1000, so the shares add back to the total.

Common Mistakes

  1. The slip: Checking against a transformed equation instead of the original

    Instead: extraneous roots pass the squared step but fail the original; always substitute into the starting equation

  2. The slip: Skipping the check after squaring or clearing denominators

    Instead: these are exactly the steps that introduce false solutions

  3. The slip: Evaluating only one side

    Instead: compute the left and right sides separately and confirm they are equal, not just that one side computes


Mini Practice

Try these on your own. Tap Reveal when you want to check.

  1. Is x=4 a solution of 3x−5=2x−1? Check both sides.

    Hint: Substitute 4 into the left side and the right side separately.

  2. Is x=−2 a solution of x2+3x=2?

    Hint: Square −2 carefully, then add 3(−2).

  3. Which of x=5 and x=6 solves 2(x+3)=16?

    Hint: Substitute each value and compare with 16.

  4. Solving 2x+1=x−1 gives the candidates x=4 and x=0. Which are real solutions?

    Hint: Check each candidate in the original equation, not the squared one.

  5. You solved 19x=401 and got x≈21.1. You only want to know whether the answer is about right. Full substitution check or estimation?

    Hint: Round the numbers to something easy to multiply.

  6. To check x=2 in 3x+4=5x+1, a student computes only 3(2)+4=10 and says "it gives a number, so it works." What is missing?

    Hint: An equation has two sides.

Want the full set?

50 practice questions for this concept — free to try, every one with a complete worked solution showing the why, not just the answer.

Frequently Asked Questions

If my answer checks out, does that mean I found all the solutions?

No. A check confirms only the values you test; it cannot tell you that another solution is missing. If you solve x2=16x^2=16 and get only x=4x=4, the check works, yet x=−4x=-4 is also a solution. To be sure you have them all, look back at your steps: did you take a square root without the ±\pm, or divide by something containing xx? Those are the places solutions get lost.

What is an extraneous solution, and where does it come from?

It is a value your steps produce that fails the original equation. Squaring is the usual cause: x=3x=3 has one solution, but squaring gives x2=9x^2=9, which also allows −3-3. The squared equation is true for more values than the original, so its solutions include extras. Multiplying both sides by an expression that can be 0, such as x−1x-1, adds extras in the same way.

What if the two sides are close but not exactly equal?

That depends on whether you rounded. If your answer is a rounded decimal, such as x≈1.414x\approx1.414 for x2=2x^2=2, the check gives 1.9993961.999396, which is close enough to accept. If your answer is exact, such as a whole number or a fraction, the two sides must match exactly; a near miss then means an arithmetic slip, either in solving or in the check itself.

Can I check an answer faster than redoing all the arithmetic?

Often, yes. Use easy mental arithmetic: for 12x−7=8912x-7=89 with your answer x=8x=8, 12×8=9612\times8=96 and 96−7=8996-7=89, done in your head. Another quick test is sign and size: if a problem about sharing $60 among friends gives each one $75, something is wrong before you substitute anything. A full written check is still best after squaring or clearing fractions, where errors hide well.

Learning Path

Checking Solutions

You are here

Next →

Nothing after this yet
You need Evaluation (substituting a value), Solution Concept (what it means for a value to satisfy an equation) and Equivalence first. This concept adds the habit of testing each answer in the original equation and rejecting any that fail. It becomes essential for radical, rational and absolute-value equations, where correct algebra can produce extraneous answers, and for checking solutions to systems and word problems.

See Also