Example 1 — Vinegar and baking soda: is it a reaction?
Show the steps and the answer
List what you started with: vinegar (acetic acid in water) and baking soda (sodium bicarbonate, a white solid).
To decide whether something new formed, you first need to know what was there before.
Look at the bubbles: a gas appeared, and it put out a flame.
Neither starting material was a gas. A gas that smothers a flame here is carbon dioxide, a new substance.
Note the other clues: the cup cooled by itself, and the solid was used up rather than just hidden.
A temperature change you did not cause and a solid that disappears both point to bonds breaking and forming.
Write it in words: acetic acid + sodium bicarbonate → sodium acetate + water + carbon dioxide.
The products have different names and formulas from the starting substances, so this is a reaction, not just mixing.
Answer: Yes. A new gas (carbon dioxide) formed, the temperature dropped on its own, and the baking soda was used up, so new substances were made.
Takeaway: Look for evidence of a new substance, and back it up with more than one clue.