Example 1 — Classify two caffeine studies
Show the steps and the answer
Study A: the researchers only recorded existing coffee habits, so it is observational.
No one was given a treatment; people chose how much coffee to drink.
Study A's gap: , an association that may be confounded by sleep, smoking or stress.
People who drink a lot of coffee can differ from others in ways that also affect blood pressure.
Study B: the researchers assigned caffeine or placebo at random, so it is an experiment.
Random assignment spreads the other factors evenly, so the groups differ systematically only in the pill.
Study B's gap: , evidence that caffeine raises blood pressure in the short term, for volunteers like these.
The volunteers were not a random sample of all adults, so the causal conclusion applies most safely to similar people.
Answer: A is observational and shows an association of 6 points. B is an experiment and gives evidence that caffeine causes a short-term rise of about 6 points in volunteers like those studied.
Takeaway: Classify by who chose the treatment; then say "is associated with" for observation and "causes" only for a randomized experiment.