Temperature Physics Example 4

Follow the full solution, then compare it with the other examples linked below.

Example 4

hard
Two objects are at 200Ā K200 \text{ K} and 400Ā K400 \text{ K}. One student says the hotter object is 'twice as hot.' Is this correct? Explain using the concept of absolute temperature and average kinetic energy.

Solution

  1. 1
    On the Kelvin scale, temperature is proportional to average kinetic energy of particles: KEavg=32kBTKE_{\text{avg}} = \frac{3}{2}k_B T.
  2. 2
    At 400Ā K400 \text{ K}, the average KE is indeed twice that at 200Ā K200 \text{ K}, so in terms of thermal energy, the statement is correct.
  3. 3
    However, converting to Celsius: 200Ā K=āˆ’73°C200 \text{ K} = -73°\text{C} and 400Ā K=127°C400 \text{ K} = 127°\text{C}. In Celsius, 127127 is not twice āˆ’73-73, showing that 'twice as hot' only makes physical sense on an absolute (Kelvin) scale.

Answer

CorrectĀ onlyĀ onĀ theĀ KelvinĀ scale,Ā whereĀ temperatureĀ relatesĀ toĀ molecularĀ kineticĀ energy.\text{Correct only on the Kelvin scale, where temperature relates to molecular kinetic energy.}
Ratios of temperature only have physical meaning on an absolute scale (Kelvin or Rankine). The Kelvin scale directly reflects molecular kinetic energy, making it the scientifically preferred scale.

About Temperature

A measure of the average kinetic energy of the particles in a substance, determining how hot or cold it is.

Learn more about Temperature →

More Temperature Examples