Implicit differentiation finds dxdy from an equation relating x and y without first solving for y: differentiate both sides with respect to x, treating y as a function of x so every y-term picks up a dxdy, then solve algebraically.
For F(x,y)=0: differentiate both sides with respect to x, apply chain rule to y-terms, solve for dxdy.
Quick Answer
Implicit differentiation finds dxdy from an equation relating x and y without first solving for y: differentiate both sides with respect to x, treating y as a function of x so every y-term picks up a dxdy, then solve algebraically. Use it for circles, ellipses and curves like x3+y3=6xy, where y is not a single function of x or is too hard to isolate. The slope formula usually contains both x and y, so you need a point on the curve to get a number.
Why This Matters
Many relationships come as equations rather than formulas: a circle x2+y2=r2, an elliptical orbit, the gas law PV=k. Implicit differentiation gives slopes and tangent lines for all of them without solving for y, which is often impossible. It is also the engine of related rates and the way to derive dxdlnx=x1. Forgetting that y depends on x gives a slope that is silently wrong.
Intuitive Explanation
The circle x2+y2=25 is not the graph of one function: each x between −5 and 5 has two y-values. Still, at the point (3,4) the circle has a definite tangent line. Implicit differentiation finds its slope by treating y as some unknown function of x near that point and differentiating both sides of the equation with respect to x.
The only new step is the chain rule on y-terms. dxd(x2)=2x as usual, but dxd(y2)=2ydxdy, because y2 squares the inner function y(x). So 2x+2ydxdy=0, and solving gives dxdy=−yx. At (3,4) the slope is −43, and at (3,−4) it is +43: one formula covers both halves of the circle, which is why it keeps y in it. Mixed terms need the product rule as well: dxd(xy)=y+xdxdy.
When y is already alone on one side, as in y=x2+x, differentiate directly. Doing it implicitly gives dxdy=2x+2x1 anyway, just with an extra step. The giveaway for implicit differentiation is x and y tangled together. If instead both x and y change with time and you differentiate with respect to t, the same technique becomes related rates.
Think of it like this.Treat y like a puppet on strings held by x: move x and y moves too, so the change in any y-term picks up the factor dxdy, how far the puppet moves per unit of hand movement. Unlike a puppet, a curve such as a circle can have two y-values for one x, so the slope formula needs y to tell them apart.
Core idea.When you can't isolate y, differentiate the whole equation and attach dxdy to each y-term via the chain rule, then solve.
When to Use
Use it when an equation mixes **x and y** in a way that is hard or impossible to solve for y: circles and ellipses, terms like xy, sin(xy) or y3+y, and the question asks for a slope or tangent line at a given point. It also produces the derivatives of inverse functions such as lnx and arcsinx. If y is already a formula in x, differentiate directly. If the quantities change with time and you want rates, it becomes related rates.
Tip.Ask: Is y tied to x by an equation I can't easily solve for y, and do I need its derivative?
How to Recognize It
Look at how x and y appear in the equation, which variable you differentiate with respect to, and whether a point on the curve is given.
1.
Is the derivative taken with respect to x, rather than with respect to time?
With respect to x gives a slope dxdy, the job here. If quantities change over time and you need dtdV, it is related rates: the same chain-rule step, but every variable gets a time derivative.
2.
Does the curve have more than one y for some x, like a circle?
Yes favours implicit differentiation, since solving would split the circle into y=±25−x2 and force you to pick a branch. If y is a single, easily isolated formula, ordinary explicit differentiation works just as well.
3.
Is a specific point on the curve given?
Yes means substitute both its x and its y into dxdy to get a number. Check first that the point satisfies the equation; without a point, the answer stays a formula in x and y.
4.
Does the question ask where the tangent is horizontal or vertical?
Then set the numerator of dxdy to 0 for horizontal tangents, or the denominator to 0 for vertical ones, and solve together with the curve's equation to find the actual points.
Implicit Differentiation compared with Explicit differentiation, Chain rule, and Related rates
All four rows rely on the chain rule, so the working looks the same on paper. Ask whether y is already isolated, whether you differentiate with respect to x or to time t, and whether you mean the rule or the method built on it.
Implicit Differentiation compared with Explicit differentiation, Chain rule, and Related rates
Type
Meaning
Key test
Formula
Example
Implicit Differentiation
Use this when an equation mixes x and y and you need the slope but can't (or won't) solve for y explicitly.
Is y tied to x by an equation I can't easily solve for y, and do I need its derivative?
For F(x,y)=0: differentiate both sides with respect to x, apply chain rule to y-terms, solve for dxdy.
Find dxdy for x2+y2=25, then the slope at (3,4).
Explicit differentiation
Differentiates a function already in y=f(x) form, no dxdy tags needed.
Use when you can write y alone on one side first.
dxdy=f′(x)
y=x2⇒y′=2x
Chain rule
The rule you APPLY to each y-term; implicit differentiation is its repeated use.
Use chain rule as the mechanism inside implicit differentiation.
dxdf(g(x))=f′(g)g′
dxd(y2)=2yy′
Related rates
Differentiates implicitly with respect to TIME t, not x.
Use when quantities change over time and you want dtd.
dtd of the relation
balloon volume vs radius over time
Implicit Differentiation
Meaning
Use this when an equation mixes x and y and you need the slope but can't (or won't) solve for y explicitly.
Key test
Is y tied to x by an equation I can't easily solve for y, and do I need its derivative?
Formula
For F(x,y)=0: differentiate both sides with respect to x, apply chain rule to y-terms, solve for dxdy.
Example
Find dxdy for x2+y2=25, then the slope at (3,4).
Explicit differentiation
Meaning
Differentiates a function already in y=f(x) form, no dxdy tags needed.
Key test
Use when you can write y alone on one side first.
Formula
dxdy=f′(x)
Example
y=x2⇒y′=2x
Chain rule
Meaning
The rule you APPLY to each y-term; implicit differentiation is its repeated use.
Key test
Use chain rule as the mechanism inside implicit differentiation.
Formula
dxdf(g(x))=f′(g)g′
Example
dxd(y2)=2yy′
Related rates
Meaning
Differentiates implicitly with respect to TIME t, not x.
Key test
Use when quantities change over time and you want dtd.
Formula
dtd of the relation
Example
balloon volume vs radius over time
Formula & Notation
For F(x,y)=0: differentiate both sides with respect to x, apply chain rule to y-terms, solve for dxdy.
If F(x,y)=0 defines y implicitly as a differentiable function of x, then by the chain rule: ∂x∂F+∂y∂F⋅dxdy=0, so dxdy=−Fy(x,y)Fx(x,y) provided Fy(x,y)=0.
How to read it:dxdy found implicitly. Alternatively, dxdy=−FyFx where Fx and Fy are partial derivatives of F(x,y).
Worked Examples
Example 1 — Slope on a circle
Easy
Find dxdy for x2+y2=25, then the slope at (3,4).
Show the steps and the answer
Differentiate each term with respect to x: 2x, then 2ydxdy, then 0 for the constant 25.
y is a function of x, so the chain rule attaches dxdy to the y-term.
Write the result: 2x+2ydxdy=0.
Both sides of the equation stay equal after differentiating.
Solve: dxdy=−2y2x=−yx.
Move the x-term across and divide by the coefficient of dxdy.
Substitute (3,4): −43. Check: the radius to (3,4) has slope 34, and 34⋅(−43)=−1.
A tangent to a circle is perpendicular to the radius, so their slopes multiply to −1.
Answer:dxdy=−yx=−43 at (3,4)
Takeaway:Tag every y-term with dxdy, then solve; the slope formula needs the point's y-value as well as its x-value.
Example 2 — Already explicit
Standard
Find dxdy for y=x2+x.
Show the steps and the answer
Notice that y is already isolated: y=x2+x1/2.
y is an explicit function of x, so there is nothing to untangle.
Differentiate term by term with the power rule: 2x+21x−1/2.
The power rule brings down the exponent 21 and lowers it by 1.
Rewrite: dxdy=2x+2x1.
Differentiating both sides implicitly would give 1⋅dxdy=2x+2x1, the same result with an extra step.
Answer:dxdy=2x+2x1
Takeaway:Implicit differentiation is for tangled equations; when y=f(x) is given, differentiate directly.
Example 3 — Find the mistake: the mixed term
Application
Find the slope of x2+xy+y2=7 at (1,2). Sam writes: "2x+dxdy+2ydxdy=0, so dxdy=−1+2y2x=−52." Find the mistake and correct it.
Show the steps and the answer
Find Sam's error: he differentiated xy as dxdy alone.
xy is a product of two functions of x, so it needs the product rule.
Use the product rule: dxd(xy)=1⋅y+xdxdy.
Differentiate x (giving 1) times y, plus x times the derivative of y.
Redo the equation: 2x+y+xdxdy+2ydxdy=0, so dxdy(x+2y)=−(2x+y).
Collect every dxdy term on one side before dividing.
Solve and substitute: dxdy=−x+2y2x+y=−1+42+2=−54.
Sam's −52 missed the y in the numerator and the x in the denominator, both from the product rule.
Answer:dxdy=−x+2y2x+y, so the slope at (1,2) is −54.
Takeaway:A term containing both x and y is a product: use the product rule and tag the y-part with dxdy.
Where You'll See It
Squeezing a gas
At constant temperature a gas obeys PV=k. Differentiating with respect to P gives V+PdPdV=0, so dPdV=−PV. At 2 atm and 10 L, the volume is shrinking by 5 L for each extra atmosphere of pressure at that moment.
Trading apples for oranges
Economists draw indifference curves such as xy=36: all mixes of x apples and y oranges a shopper likes equally. Implicitly, y+xdxdy=0, so dxdy=−xy. At (4,9) the shopper would give up 49=2.25 oranges for one more apple.
Steering around an elliptical track
On the track 100x2+25y2=1, differentiating gives 50x+252ydxdy=0, so dxdy=−4yx. At (8,3) the car points along slope −32, the direction its headlights shine.
Common Mistakes
The slip:Differentiating a y-term without attaching dxdy
Instead:dxd(y3)=3y2dxdy, because y depends on x.
The slip:Forgetting the product rule on mixed xy-terms
Instead:dxd(xy)=y+xdxdy, not just dxdy.
The slip:Leaving dxdy unsolved
Instead:after differentiating, collect all dxdy terms and solve for it explicitly.
Mini Practice
Try these on your own. Tap Reveal when you want to check.
1.
Find dxdy for y2=4x, then find the slope at (1,2).
Hint:Differentiate both sides; the left side needs a factor of dxdy.
2.
Find the slope of x2+xy+y2=7 at the point (1,2).
Hint:The xy term needs the product rule. Collect the dxdy terms on one side.
3.
Find the slope of the curve x3+y3=6xy at the point (3,3).
Hint:Differentiate both sides, using the product rule on 6xy, then substitute x=3, y=3.
4.
Find the equation of the tangent line to the ellipse x2+4y2=8 at (2,1).
Hint:Get the slope by implicit differentiation, then use the point-slope form.
5.
You need dxdy for y=xx2+1 and for xy+y2=6. Which one needs implicit differentiation?
Hint:In which equation is y already alone on one side?
6.
For xy=12, a student writes "dxd(xy)=dxdy, so dxdy=0." Correct the work.
Hint:xy is a product of two things that both depend on x.
Want the full set?
50 practice questions for this concept — free to try, every one with a complete worked
solution showing the why, not just the answer.
Why does y2 differentiate to 2ydxdy but x2 only to 2x?
Both follow the chain rule. The derivative of the outer square is twice the inside, times the derivative of the inside with respect to x. For x2 the inside is x, whose derivative is 1, so that factor is invisible. For y2 the inside is y, which changes with x at the rate dxdy, so the factor shows up.
How does implicit differentiation give the derivative of lnx?
Write y=lnx as ey=x. Differentiating both sides with respect to x gives eydxdy=1, so dxdy=ey1, and since ey=x, that is x1. The same trick on siny=x gives dxdy=cosy1=1−x21, the derivative of arcsinx, using cosy≥0 on its range. Any inverse function can be handled this way, because its defining equation is easier to differentiate than its formula.
What does it mean if dxdy comes out as 00 at a point?
It usually marks a point where the curve is not a single smooth branch. For y2=x2(x+1), implicit differentiation gives dxdy=2y3x2+2x, which is 00 at the origin. There the curve crosses itself, with two tangent lines of slopes 1 and −1, so no single slope exists and each branch must be studied separately.
Can I differentiate with respect to y instead of x?
Yes, and sometimes it is easier. Treating x as a function of y gives dydx, and wherever dydx=0, the slope is dxdy=1/dydx. For the curve x=y3+y, dydx=3y2+1, so dxdy=3y2+11 without ever solving the cubic for y. The trick pays off whenever x is a simple formula in y but y has no neat formula in x.
You need Derivative, Differentiation Rules (power, product, quotient) and above all the Chain Rule, which supplies the dxdy on every y-term. Implicit differentiation finds slopes on curves defined by equations, such as x2+y2=25, without solving for y. Next, Related Rates applies the same move with respect to time, linking how fast connected quantities change.