Hidden Variables Math Example 4

Follow the full solution, then compare it with the other examples linked below.

Example 4

medium
In the equation x+3=7x + 3 = 7, if xx is constrained to be a natural number, solve it. If xx must be a real number, what changes? Identify the hidden variable (domain).

Solution

  1. 1
    Solution: x=4x = 4 regardless of domain.
  2. 2
    Hidden variable: the domain. For N\mathbb{N}: x=4x = 4 is valid. For R\mathbb{R}: x=4x = 4 is also valid.
  3. 3
    Now consider x+3=2x + 3 = 2: for N\mathbb{N} (positive integers), x=āˆ’1x = -1 which is not in N\mathbb{N} — no solution. For Z\mathbb{Z} or R\mathbb{R}: x=āˆ’1x = -1 is valid.
  4. 4
    The domain is a hidden variable that determines whether a solution exists.

Answer

DomainĀ isĀ aĀ hiddenĀ variable;Ā x+3=2Ā hasĀ noĀ solutionĀ inĀ NĀ butĀ x=āˆ’1∈Z\text{Domain is a hidden variable; } x+3=2 \text{ has no solution in }\mathbb{N} \text{ but }x=-1 \in \mathbb{Z}
The domain over which an equation is solved is often implicit — a hidden variable that drastically affects what solutions exist. Specifying the domain explicitly removes this ambiguity.

About Hidden Variables

Quantities or factors that influence a mathematical or real-world situation but are not explicitly included in the current model or expression.

Learn more about Hidden Variables →

More Hidden Variables Examples