Example 1 — Ice cream and drowning
Show the steps and the answer
List what drives each quantity: ice cream sales rise on hot days; drownings rise when more people swim, which also happens on hot days.
A factor that pushes both quantities up at once can create a correlation with no direct link between them.
Name the hidden variable: temperature, which tracks the season.
It was missing from the original comparison, yet it drives both measured quantities.
Compare like with like: suppose hot weeks average 12 drownings whether ice cream sales are high or low, and cool weeks average 3 either way.
With temperature held fixed, sales make no difference, so the original link came entirely from temperature.
Check the mechanism: there is no plausible way eating ice cream causes drowning, while heat plainly increases swimming.
A causal story that works only through the third factor supports the hidden-variable explanation.
Answer: No — summer heat is the hidden variable
Takeaway: When two things rise and fall together, look for a third factor driving both, and compare within levels of that factor before claiming a cause.