Take a team roster: Ana, Ben, Cai, Dee. Ana is a member, so in set language Ana ∈ Roster. Eli is not, so Eli ∈/ Roster. Each test asks about one object, and the answer is yes or no. There is no partial membership: Ben is not 'mostly' on the team, and 5 is not 'almost' in {2,4,6,8} just because it is close to 4 and 6.
For a set given by a rule, you test membership by checking the rule. With E={x:x is even}, 14∈E because 14=2⋅7, and 15∈/E because 15 leaves remainder 1 when divided by 2. You never need the whole list, which is lucky, since E has infinitely many members.
Elements can themselves be sets, and that is where students slip. In A={1,2,3} the number 2 is an element, but {2} is not: {2} is a set, and A contains only numbers. The claim '{2} fits inside A' is true, but it is a different relation, subset, written {2}⊆A. Now flip it with B={{1,2},3}: here {1,2}∈B but 1∈/B, because the two elements of B are a set and the number 3.
Think of it like this. Membership works like a ticket scanner at a concert gate: it checks one ticket at a time and shows green or red, never 'partly valid'. A scanner only answers for a single ticket; asking whether a whole bundle of tickets is good is a different question, the subset question.
Core idea. An element is one individual member of a set, and membership is a sharp yes-or-no.