Picture two circles, one drawn completely inside the other. The small circle is 'students in the school band', the big one is 'students at the school'. Every band member is a student, so Band ⊆ School: nothing in the small circle pokes outside. The reverse is false, since plenty of students are not in the band.
To check A⊆B with lists, go through A one member at a time. For A={2,4} and B={1,2,3,4,5}: 2 is in B and 4 is in B, so yes. The test can fail on a single member: add 7 to A and the answer becomes no, even though two of the three members still pass. Two special cases follow from the rule. A⊆A for any set, and ∅⊆A, because the empty set has no member that could fail.
Sharing members is not the same as fitting inside. {1,2,9} and {1,2,3} share two members, but 9 lies outside the second set and 3 outside the first, so neither is a subset of the other. Their overlap {1,2} is the intersection, a new set; subset is a yes-or-no relation between two sets. Keep the symbols apart too: {1,2}⊆{1,2,3} compares two sets, while 1∈{1,2,3} compares one number with a set.
Think of it like this. Your phone's Favorites are a subset of your contacts: every favourite is also a saved contact, and you can't star someone who isn't saved. If you star every contact, Favorites is still a subset, just equal to the whole list, the same way every set is a subset of itself.
Core idea. A is a subset of B when every single member of A is also a member of B.