On this concept: Formula

Not sure which lesson to do first? Find your level and get a plan →

Math · Statistics & Probability · Grade 6-8

Dependence (Statistical)

Statistical dependence means knowing that one event occurred changes the probability of another, so P(B∣A)≠P(B).

P(A

Quick Answer

Statistical dependence means knowing that one event occurred changes the probability of another, so P(B∣A)≠P(B). It shows up whenever the first result changes the situation for the second: cards drawn without putting them back, students picked one at a time for a team, or a rainy day making the next day's rain more likely. For dependent events, multiply the first probability by the updated second one, P(A)×P(B∣A), instead of multiplying the two original probabilities.

Why This Matters

Using the independent rule on dependent events gives wrong answers that look reasonable. The chance of drawing two aces from the top of a deck is 452×351=1221, not (452)2=1169. Spotting dependence also tells you when information is useful: if knowing A shifts the odds of B, then A is a clue worth having.

Intuitive Explanation

A bag holds 5 marbles: 2 red and 3 blue. Draw one and look: it is red. Keep it out. Now the bag holds 4 marbles and only 1 is red, so the chance the next marble is red has dropped from 25 to 14. The first draw changed what is left, and that is dependence: the second event's probability depends on what happened first.

Had the first marble been blue, the bag would hold 2 red out of 4, and the chance of red would rise to 24=12. The second probability moves with the first result, which is why it is written P(B∣A), read 'the probability of B given A'. To find the chance that both happen, multiply the first probability by the updated second one: P(red, red)=25×14=110.

Put the marble back before the second draw and the bag is restored: the second draw is red with probability 25 whatever came first. That is independence, and only then is P(A)×P(B) correct. Dependence is also weaker than causation. Umbrella sales and rained-out baseball games are dependent, yet umbrellas do not cancel games; rain drives both.

Think of it like this. Dependent events are like sharing a pizza. Once someone takes a pepperoni slice, fewer pepperoni slices remain, so the next person's chance of getting one drops. If slices were put back (not recommended), the next person would face the original pizza, which is independence. The pizza fits draws without replacement best; dependence can also come from a shared cause, such as weather.

Core idea. Two events are dependent when P(B∣A)≠P(B) — learning A happened shifts B's probability.


When to Use

Look for dependence when one result changes the pool or the conditions for the next: draws without replacement, choosing people one at a time, or two events linked by a common factor. The phrase given that is a strong signal. Multiply by the updated probability, P(A)×P(B∣A). If items are replaced, or the events come from separate processes like a coin and a die, they are independent and the plain probabilities multiply.

Tip. Ask: Does knowing the first event occurred change the probability of the second?

How to Recognize It

Before you multiply two probabilities, look at what happens between the two events: whether something is removed and kept out, whether they come from separate objects, or whether one shared factor affects both.

  1. Is something taken out and kept out before the second pick, such as a card set aside or a student already chosen?

    If yes, the pool has shrunk and its mix has changed, so the events are dependent: 2 kings in a row is 452×351. If each card goes back, the deck resets and the events are independent.

  2. Do the two events come from separate objects, like a coin and a die, or two different spinners?

    If yes, nothing links them, so they are independent and P(A)×P(B) works. Separate objects that cannot affect each other are the clearest sign of independence.

  3. Could one shared factor push both events, such as hot weather raising both ice cream sales and beach visits?

    If yes, the events are dependent even though neither one causes the other. Dependence only says the chances are linked; whether one event produces the other is a question of causation.

  4. Is the question asking for the updated number itself, such as the chance of a second king after a first?

    Then you are computing a conditional probability, P(B∣A)=351. Dependence is the yes-or-no fact that this number differs from the original 452.

Dependence (Statistical) compared with Independent events, Conditional probability, and Causation

Dependence, independence, conditional probability and causation all describe how two events relate, so a link in the numbers is easily read as a cause. Ask whether you need a yes-or-no answer about linked chances, the updated chance itself, or proof that one event makes the other happen.

Dependence (Statistical)

Meaning
Use this when an earlier outcome changes the probability of a later one, such as drawing without replacement.
Key test
Does knowing the first event occurred change the probability of the second?
Formula
P(A and B)=P(A)×P(B∣A)
Example
A bag has 2 red and 3 blue marbles. You draw two without replacing. P(both red)?

Independent events

Meaning
Are when one event has no effect on the other's probability.
Key test
Use when outcomes don't influence each other, like with replacement.
Formula
P(A and B)=P(A)P(B)
Example
Two separate coin flips

Conditional probability

Meaning
Is the number P(B∣A); dependence is whether that number differs from P(B).
Key test
Use when you need the updated probability itself.
Formula
P(B∣A)=P(A∩B)P(A)
Example
Chance of red given first was red

Causation

Meaning
Means A actually produces B, a stronger claim than mere dependence.
Key test
Use when an intervention on A changes B, not just shared information.
Example
Studying causes higher scores

Formula & Notation

P(A and B)=P(A)×P(B∣A)
A and B are dependent if P(A∩B)≠P(A)⋅P(B); then P(A∩B)=P(A)⋅P(B∣A)

How to read it: P(B∣A)≠P(B) indicates that A and B are dependent

Worked Examples

Example 1 — Two draws without replacement

Easy

A bag has 2 red and 3 blue marbles. You draw two without replacing. P(both red)?
Show the steps and the answer
  1. Find the first probability: P(1st red)=25.

    2 of the 5 marbles are red.

  2. Update the bag: after a red is removed, 1 red and 3 blue remain, 4 in all.

    Without replacement the second draw comes from a different bag, so the events are dependent.

  3. Find the second probability given the first: P(2nd red∣1st red)=14.

    1 of the 4 remaining marbles is red.

  4. Multiply: 25×14=220=110.

    For dependent events, P(A and B)=P(A)×P(B∣A).

Answer: 220=110

Takeaway: Update the counts after each draw without replacement, then multiply. Both red happens 1 time in 10.

Example 2 — Independent version

Standard

Same bag, but you replace the first marble before the second draw. P(both red)?
Show the steps and the answer
  1. Find the first probability: P(1st red)=25.

    The starting bag is the same as before.

  2. Restore the bag: the red marble goes back, so 2 red and 3 blue are there again.

    Replacement undoes the first draw, so the second draw cannot be affected by it.

  3. Multiply the unchanged probabilities: 25×25=425.

    With independent draws P(B∣A)=P(B), so the plain product is correct.

  4. Compare: 425=0.16, against 110=0.10 without replacement.

    Removing a red marble makes a second red less likely, which is why the dependent answer is smaller.

Answer: 25×25=425

Takeaway: Replacing the first item makes the draws independent. The same bag gives 425 instead of 110.

Example 3 — Find the mistake: choosing two representatives

Application

A class has 12 girls and 8 boys. Two different students are chosen at random, one after the other, as class representatives. Max writes: "P(both girls)=1220×1220=925." Find the mistake and correct it.
Show the steps and the answer
  1. Check the first factor: P(1st girl)=1220 is right.

    12 of the 20 students are girls.

  2. Find the error: the same student cannot be chosen twice, so after a girl is picked, 11 girls remain among 19 students.

    Max used the original class for the second pick, as if the first girl had been put back.

  3. Use the updated probability: P(2nd girl∣1st girl)=1119.

    The pool changed, so the two picks are dependent.

  4. Multiply: 1220×1119=132380=3395≈0.347.

    This is a little below Max's 925=0.36, because removing one girl lowers the chance of picking another.

Answer: P(both girls)=1220×1119=3395≈0.347

Takeaway: When choosing without replacement, update the counts before writing the second probability.

Where You'll See It

  • Being dealt two hearts

    The chance that the top two cards of a shuffled deck are both hearts is 1352×1251=117, about 5.9%. Treating the cards as independent would give (14)2=116, too high, because the first heart is gone when the second card is dealt.

  • Rainy days come in runs

    Weather systems often last more than a day, so in many places the chance of rain tomorrow is noticeably higher after a rainy day than on an average day. Forecasters build in that dependence; a model that treated each day as independent would forecast worse.

Common Mistakes

  1. The slip: Multiplying P(A)×P(B) for dependent events

    Instead: use P(A)×P(B∣A) instead.

  2. The slip: Forgetting the pool changed

    Instead: after a draw without replacement, update the counts before the next probability.

  3. The slip: Equating dependence with causation

    Instead: linked probabilities don't prove one causes the other.


Mini Practice

Try these on your own. Tap Reveal when you want to check.

  1. A box has 4 red and 6 blue pens. You take 2 without putting the first back. What is P(both blue)?

    Hint: After one blue is taken, how many blue pens and total pens are left?

  2. A class has 12 girls and 8 boys. Two students are picked one after the other. What is the probability the first is a girl and the second is a boy?

    Hint: The second pick comes from 19 students.

  3. Two cards are drawn from a standard 52-card deck without replacement. What is the probability both are hearts?

    Hint: Update both the number of hearts and the deck size for the second card.

  4. Of 100 students, 40 have a pet, and 30 of those 40 walk to school. In all, 60 students walk. Are "has a pet" and "walks" dependent?

    Hint: Compare P(walks) with P(walks∣pet).

  5. In a town, sunburns are more common on days with high ice-cream sales, so the two events are dependent. Does buying ice cream cause sunburn?

    Hint: Dependence tells you the events are linked. Does it tell you why?

  6. A bag has 5 green and 5 yellow balls. Two are drawn without replacement. Zoe writes: "P(both green)=12×12=14." Correct her.

    Hint: What is the chance of green on the second draw once a green is gone?

Want the full set?

50 practice questions for this concept — free to try, every one with a complete worked solution showing the why, not just the answer.

Frequently Asked Questions

If A depends on B, does B also depend on A?

Yes, always. If knowing B changes the chance of A, then knowing A changes the chance of B. In a class where some students play a sport, being on the soccer team makes 'plays a sport' certain, and knowing a student plays a sport makes 'on the soccer team' more likely than it is for a random student. Dependence runs both ways, even when a cause runs only one way.

Do sports players really get a hot hand, or are their shots independent?

This was argued about for decades. A famous 1985 study of basketball shooting found that hits and misses looked independent, so the hot hand seemed to be an illusion. In 2018, economists Joshua Miller and Adam Sanjurjo showed that the study's method had a hidden bias toward finding independence; corrected, the same data show a modest hot-hand effect. Whether one shot changes the chance of the next is a dependence question, and it proved harder to measure than it looked.

Is grabbing two marbles at once different from drawing them one after the other?

No. Grabbing two together gives the same chances as drawing one at a time without replacement, because either way you end up with two different marbles. One after the other just makes the counting easy: 58×47=514\frac{5}{8} \times \frac{4}{7} = \frac{5}{14} for two reds from 5 red and 3 green. Counting pairs gives the same answer: 10 red pairs out of 28 possible pairs.

Learning Path

Dependence (Statistical)

You are here

You need Probability and Independent Events first, including the rule P(A∩B)=P(A)P(B), which holds only when one event does not change the other's chances. Dependence covers the cases where it does, using P(A)×P(B∣A). Next, Conditional Probability gives the full method for finding P(B∣A), and Causation asks when a dependence means one thing actually produces the other.

See Also