Example 1 — How much did knowing add?
Show the steps and the answer
Difference between the trials: points.
The cream was the same in both trials, so the shrinking gap points to bias that blinding removed.
Participant blinding: an identical placebo cream, so control patients also expected to improve.
Patients who knew they had no treatment could report less change, which would widen the gap.
Assessor blinding: tubes coded like A-117, key held outside the study until all ratings were done.
Doctors who cannot tell the groups apart cannot rate one group more generously, even without meaning to.
Best estimate of the cream's effect: about 1.2 points.
Only the double-blind trial compares groups with equal expectations and equal treatment by the raters.
Answer: About 1.9 of the 3.1 points were likely bias. Patient blinding equalized expectations, assessor blinding equalized the ratings, and the cream's effect is about 1.2 points.
Takeaway: When outcomes involve judgment, compare blinded and unblinded results: the difference shows how much knowledge can tilt the data.