Put $200 in an account that pays 5% simple interest. Each year the bank pays 5% of $200, which is $10. The payment stays $10 every year, because the bank looks only at the original $200, never at the interest you have already collected. After 1, 2 and 3 years the balance is $210, $220 and $230: the same jump each year, so a graph of the balance is a straight line.
That is all the formula says. P×r is one year's interest, and multiplying by t counts how many years of it you collect, so I=200×0.05×3=30 dollars. The units have to agree: an annual rate needs the time in years, so 6 months is t=0.5 and 18 months is t=1.5. The rate must be a decimal, 5%=0.05; multiplying by 5 instead makes the interest 100 times too big.
Compound interest starts out identical and then drifts away. At 5% compounded yearly, year 1 pays $10, but year 2 pays 5% of $210, which is $10.50, and year 3 pays about $11.03. So look at the yearly payments: if each one is figured on a bigger balance than the last, the interest compounds; if every payment is the same, it is simple.
Think of it like this. Simple interest is rent paid on money. Rent your bike to a neighbour for $10 a month and the rent you collect sits in a jar earning nothing; only the bike earns. In the same way only the principal earns interest, so every year pays the same. Unlike bike rent, the payment is set as a percent of what you lent.
Core idea. Simple interest pays a fixed amount each period because it is always computed on the starting principal, never on interest already earned.