Example 1 — Equals sign model
Show the steps and the answer
Read the chain literally: it claims , that is, .
Taken at face value, the line says two different numbers are equal.
Name the model behind it: "=" means "and the answer is", so the student keeps writing the next computation.
This model works for alone, which is why it survives until a chain of steps appears.
Test the model: ask whether is true. A student with this model often says it's "backwards".
A model that can't accept the answer on the left is the "answer comes next" model, confirmed.
Replace it with the balance model, where "=" means both sides have the same value, and rewrite: , then .
Each line now balances, and , and the new model also accepts .
Answer: The 'do the next step' model is wrong; use the balance model
Takeaway: When an error repeats, name the model that produces it, test it on a case where it predicts wrong, and swap in one that predicts right.