Consistency (Meta) Examples: 43 Problems with Answers

Worked examples of Consistency (Meta) to try before you open each solution, then practice problems with answers.

Worked Examples

Example 1

easy
A student claims: 'The set S={x∈R:x>5 and x<3}.' Check whether this definition is consistent.
Show solution

Answer

S=∅ (the conditions are contradictory; the set is empty)

First step

1.
Examine the two conditions simultaneously: x>5 requires x to be above 5, while x<3 requires x to be below 3.

Full solution

  1. 2.
    No real number can satisfy both conditions at the same time — the requirements contradict each other.
  2. 3.
    Therefore S=∅. The definition is internally consistent (no logical error), but it defines the empty set.
A set definition is consistent if no logical contradiction prevents elements from being described — but the set may still be empty. Here the conditions are mutually exclusive, yielding the empty set.

Example 2

medium
Check whether the system of equations x+y=5 and 2x+2y=11 is consistent.

Example 3

hard
Show that adding '0=1' to ordinary arithmetic makes it inconsistent.

Practice Problems

Try each one, then open the solution to compare your method.

Example 1

easy
A proof assumes both 'n is even' and 'n is odd'. Is this assumption consistent? What follows?

Example 2

medium
Determine whether the conditions 'n is a prime number' and 'n is divisible by 4' are consistent. If so, find an example; if not, explain why.

Example 3

easy
Is the system {x+y=5, x+y=3} consistent?

Example 4

easy
Is {x=2, y=3, x+y=5} consistent?

Example 5

easy
Does the single equation x2=−1 have a real solution? Is it consistent over the reals?

Example 6

easy
Are the constraints x>0 and x<5 consistent?

Example 7

easy
Are x>5 and x<2 consistent?

Example 8

easy
A definition says '0 is both positive and negative.' Is this consistent with standard sign conventions?

Example 9

easy
Is the system {2x=4, x=2} consistent?

Example 10

easy
Can a triangle have side lengths 1,1,5? Is this consistent with the triangle inequality?

Example 11

medium
For what value of k is the system {x+y=2, 2x+2y=k} consistent?

Example 12

medium
Is it consistent to assume both 'n is the largest integer' and the rules of arithmetic?

Example 13

medium
Are the three statements a=b, b=c, a≠c consistent?

Example 14

medium
Is a consistent set of statements necessarily all true? Decide with {'unicorns have one horn', 'no unicorns exist'}.

Example 15

medium
Adding the assumption x=0 to the system {xy=1}: is it consistent?

Example 16

medium
Is the set of axioms {'every line has ≥2 points', 'there exists a line with exactly 1 point'} consistent?

Example 17

challenge
Determine all k for which {x+y+z=1, x+y=k, z=2} is consistent.

Example 18

challenge
A student claims 0.999…≠1 while accepting standard real-number axioms. Is this position consistent? Explain.

Example 19

challenge
Is it consistent to have a set S defined as 'the set of all sets that do not contain themselves'? What does this reveal?

Example 20

medium
Is the pair of constraints x+y=10 and x−y=2 consistent? If so, solve.

Example 21

medium
Is it consistent to define a0=∞ within standard real arithmetic?

Example 22

medium
Are sin⁡θ=12 and cos⁡θ=12 consistent for a single real θ?

Example 23

easy
Is the set {x∈Z:x>3 and x<8} defined by consistent conditions?

Example 24

easy
Are {a+b=10, a=4} consistent?

Example 25

medium
For which k is {x+y=3, 2x+2y=k} consistent?

Example 26

medium
Is {x2=4, x>0} consistent? If so, give the solution.

Example 27

medium
Is {x2=−4, x∈R} consistent?

Example 28

medium
Is {n is prime, n is even, n≠2} consistent?

Example 29

medium
Are the triangle-angle conditions {∠A=70∘, ∠B=60∘, ∠C=60∘} consistent?

Example 30

medium
For what b is {x+y=b, x−y=2, x=3} consistent?

Example 31

medium
Are the conditions {f(x)=x2, f(3)=10} consistent?

Example 32

medium
Determine consistency of {2x+3y=12, 4x+6y=24}.

Example 33

hard
Find all a for which {x2+y2=a, x+y=2, x=y} is consistent.

Example 34

hard
Are the statements {'P is true', '¬P is true'} consistent?

Example 35

hard
A definition states S={x:x∉x}. Is the question 'S∈S?' consistent?

Example 36

hard
For what real c is {sin⁡θ=c, θ∈R} consistent?

Example 37

hard
Determine all values of m for which {y=mx, y=2x+3, x=1} is consistent.

Example 38

challenge
A theory has axioms A1 and A2. We prove A1⇒P and A2⇒¬P. Is the theory consistent?

Example 39

challenge
Consider non-Euclidean geometry that drops the parallel postulate. Is the result consistent?

Example 40

challenge
Suppose T is consistent. Is T∪{ϕ} guaranteed consistent for any statement ϕ?

What to focus on

Core idea: A set of statements is consistent if they can all be true at once — no contradiction can be derived from them.

Common stuck point: The procedure for consistency (meta) is the easy part; the trap is confusing consistency with completeness. Asking "Can every statement in this set be true at the same time without forcing a contradiction?" first is what keeps a correct-looking calculation from being attached to the wrong concept.

Ask yourself: Can every statement in this set be true at the same time without forcing a contradiction?

Concept recap

The property of a set of mathematical statements having no internal contradictions — all statements can be simultaneously true within the same system.

A set of statements is like the rule sheet of a board game. If one rule says 'the youngest player moves first' and another says 'the oldest player moves first', the game cannot start, however sensible each rule looks alone. A mathematical contradiction is worse than a stalled game, though: it lets you prove any statement whatsoever.

Read the full lesson on Consistency (Meta)

Background knowledge

These ideas may be useful before you work through the harder examples.

logical statement