Example 1 — Stuck on derivatives
Show the steps and the answer
Separate the symptoms: the student writes correctly but cannot say what the value 2 at means.
Correct rule use with no meaning points to a missing idea underneath, not a gap in the rule.
Trace the arrows backwards: derivative, which rests on the limit of secant slopes, which rests on slope, which rests on function.
A derivative is defined as a limit of slopes, so every link in this chain is a true prerequisite.
Test the nearest links: ask for the slope of between and ; the student gets but cannot say what happens as the second point slides toward the first.
Slope works, so the break is the limit idea, the first link that fails.
Plan the repair: teach limits through shrinking secant slopes, 2.1, 2.01, 2.001, approaching 2, then return to derivatives as that limit.
Fixing the prerequisite gives the rule a meaning: the 2 in at is the value those slopes approach.
Answer: Reteach limits, then derivatives
Takeaway: When rules work but meaning is missing, walk the dependency arrows backwards and repair the first idea that fails.