Example 1 — Algebra-wide struggle
Show the steps and the answer
List what each topic needs: solving treats as an unknown number; factoring treats as any number; graphing treats as a value that varies.
Writing out the requirements shows what the three topics have in common.
Find the shared idea: all three treat a letter as a number you can operate on.
One idea upstream of all three explains all three failures; three separate gaps would be a coincidence.
Test it directly: ask what equals when , and whether and are the same.
A student who answers "24", reading as two digits side by side, or who says and differ, has a broken picture of a variable.
Repair the gateway first: practise substituting, such as in giving 7, before returning to the three topics.
Once a letter means a number, the equation, factoring and graphing lessons have something to stand on.
Answer: The variable concept is the bottleneck
Takeaway: Failures in several topics that all need one idea point to that idea; test and repair it before reteaching the topics.