Analogical Reasoning Math Example 2

Follow the full solution, then compare it with the other examples linked below.

Example 2

medium
Arithmetic has addition and multiplication. By analogy, what operations does set theory have, and what arithmetic laws transfer? Identify two laws that hold and one that does not.

Solution

  1. 1
    Analogy: addition \leftrightarrow union \cup; multiplication \leftrightarrow intersection \cap.
  2. 2
    Commutative law holds in both: a+b=b+aAB=BAa+b=b+a \leftrightarrow A\cup B=B\cup A (and similarly for \cap).
  3. 3
    Distributive law holds: a(b+c)=ab+acA(BC)=(AB)(AC)a(b+c)=ab+ac \leftrightarrow A\cap(B\cup C)=(A\cap B)\cup(A\cap C).
  4. 4
    Cancellation fails: in arithmetic, a+c=b+ca=ba+c=b+c \Rightarrow a=b. But AC=BCA\cup C=B\cup C does not imply A=BA=B (e.g., if ACA\subset C and BCB\subset C, then AC=BC=CA\cup C=B\cup C=C for any A,BCA,B\subseteq C).

Answer

Holds: commutativity, distributivity. Fails: cancellation under \text{Holds: commutativity, distributivity. Fails: cancellation under }\cup
Analogies between mathematical structures reveal which laws transfer and which do not. Testing the analogy carefully prevents the mistake of assuming every arithmetic property carries over to sets.

About Analogical Reasoning

Drawing conclusions about a new situation by recognizing its structural similarity to a better-understood situation.

Learn more about Analogical Reasoning →

More Analogical Reasoning Examples