Example 1 — Stakeholder analysis: scanning student messages
Show the steps and the answer
List the stakeholders: students in danger, every student whose messages are read, the counselors who handle alerts, parents, and the company that stores the messages.
Each group gains or loses something different, and the company is easy to forget even though it holds the data.
Measure the benefit and the cost: 4 real concerns found, but of alerts were false.
Each false alert means a student called in over a joke or a complaint about homework. Numbers turn "it keeps kids safe" and "it's creepy" into claims you can weigh.
Check consent and data use: do students and parents know messages are scanned, and how long are they kept?
Monitoring that people don't know about can't be questioned, and stored messages can later be used for purposes nobody agreed to.
Check for bias: compare which groups of students receive the false alerts.
If slang used more by one group triggers more alerts, those students carry more of the cost.
Recommend terms: a counselor reviews every alert before any student is contacted, families are told in writing, messages are deleted after 30 days, and false alerts are audited by group each term.
These safeguards keep the 4 real catches while cutting the harm of the 116 false ones.
Answer: Keep it only with safeguards: human review before contact, written notice to families, 30-day deletion and a regular bias audit. Without them, a 97% false-alert rate makes the harm outweigh the benefit.
Takeaway: An ethics answer names every stakeholder, puts numbers on benefits and harms where it can, and ends in a decision with its conditions.